2. anonymousbread38 2 yr. ago. Unrefrigerated Uncrustables Sandwiches should be eaten within 6-8 hours of thawing. Refrigerate Uncrustables for no more than 24 hours and consume within 8 hours of thawing. There was another thread that mentioned the tool and I'm sure it saves money in the long run. To be among the first to know of any promotions or offers, we invite you to Like our Facebook Page or sign up for our newsletter. When they are thawed, you can enjoy them just like any other Uncrustable. . Heres why: Preservation: Freezing Uncrustables helps to preserve the freshness of the sandwich. (Measurement Guide), How Long Do Pizza Hut Pizzas Take To Cook? If you eat them pretty often, or live with people who do, putting a couple in the fridge is a fine idea. Cookie Notice Its also important to note that Uncrustables contain dairy, which can spoil quickly when not refrigerated properly. However, this is not recommended as Uncrustables are best enjoyed fresh. Uncrustables bites have become popular recently as well. So uncrustables need refrigeration. All of our Uncrustablesproducts are produced in the USA at our two manufacturing facilities in Scottsville, Kentucky and Longmont, Colorado. Once thawed, Uncrustables should be eaten within eight hours for the best quality. For best product experience, we do not recommend refrigerating Uncrustables as it may dry out the bread. The best place to store Uncrustables is in the freezer where they should retain their flavor and quality for a long time. This helps to ensure that you get a fresh, delicious sandwich every time you eat an Uncrustable. Keep Uncrustables sandwiches frozen until ready to thaw. Contains Wheat And Peanut Ingredients. The texture of food, like an Uncrustable sandwich, or even homemade sandwiches, is important in determining its quality. If you arent consuming them right away, you shouldnt be leaving them out on the counter. Other flavors include honey-cinnamon, Nutella and peanut butter, strawberry cream cheese, and more. It has gone bad when you feel a slimy or stale texture when you touch it. Uncrustables should be kept frozen and refrigerated. For more information, please see our Leaving it on the dashboard of your car on a hot day is another effective method. We also suggest speaking with the manager at your preferred retailer for the best availability information locally. They should be frozen for extended periods of time. Here are a few tips to make your Uncrustables last longer in the freezer, fridge, or kitchen counter: Now that you know all about storing uncrustables and whether or not they need to be refrigerated, here are a few additional questions you might have: Uncrustables are meant to be thawed for 30 to 60 minutes at room temperature before being eaten. Naturally, you are to consume uncrustables within an hour or two. Manage Settings We do not recommend refreezing Uncrustablesproducts. This will speed up the thawing process. This is Why Pizza From Pizza Hut Make You Sick! Check the expiration date on the package to make sure its fresh. Uncrustables should always be stored in the freezer until you can enjoy them. Yes! For best the flavor experience, we recommend eating within 8 to 10 hours of defrosting. Its also best to thaw them in the fridge or in a lunchbox with an ice pack. You can leave the uncrustables on a countertop if you are sure to consume them within the recommended eating hours. Processed peanut butter makes it difficult to last a day under average room temperature. 1. lisa-frank_whore 2 yr. ago. How Long Should Uncrustable Stay Out of The Fridge? They are a common food item for homes with children to feed as not only are they convenient but also super delicious.