Irish Eyes Pub & Restaurant - New Windsor, NY - Yelp The real surpise, however, is the food. Jane McMahon, owner of Irish Eyes Bar in New Windsor, received an unexpected call . This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. Steak, Burgers, Bar Food, American, Mexican, Irish Restaurants & Irish Pubs in New Windsor. Great pub style atmosphere. Yes, Irish Eyes Pub offers takeout services. Irish Eyes Pub - A Taste of the Irish, Right Here at the Beach - Irish Reviews. Reviews for Irish Eyes Pub. 5,158 were here. The music they.play islate 60's early 70's keeping with the theme." The fish and chips came with 2 decent size pieces of fish and not an over abundance of fries but enough. was in the shower. $ - Cheap Eats (Under $10) Best burger I had in a long time. Great spot for a casual meal. You might call it pub grub, but it's straight forward and tasty. Visit here for fun, to watch sports, meet friends, have a business lunch or for dinner. I have to say they were the best fish tacos I have ever had. Are the prices at this restaurant mid-range / moderate? My friend ordered the fish and chips while I went with the fish tacos. It attracts what seems to be a loyal, and diverse crowd. years ago and for this reason we have not been backhopefully this has not happened to anyone else. Last minute choice for lunch with friends in beautiful New Windsor NY. I've eaten there several times and I've never been dispointed, in any way. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews. Irish Eyes Pub & Restaurant - American Traditional Restaurant - New Main Menu (PDF) Happy Hour Menu; Pub Grub Happy Hour Menu; Late Night Menu (PDF) Kid's Menu . This place with the nice atmosphere can be a good dining place on your route. Last minute choice for lunch with friends in beautiful New Windsor NY. I am a very responsible woman We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. Price Point All friends ordered the Cornbeaf and cabbage that was really place fills uptypical irish/American pub stylecorn beef always lean,,,great reubens onion rings are good and so is the potato saladvery friendly staffdo not rush u My friend and I stopped here last night on our way to the movies.